chicagotribune.com

 Classified
    Find a job
    Find a car
    Find real estate
    Rent an apartment
    Find a mortgage
    Dating
    Pets
    Place an ad

 Shopping
    Sales & Deals
    See newspaper ads
    Yellow pages
    Grocery coupons

 News | Opinion
  Local News
    Nation/World News
    Columnists
    Special Reports
    Obituaries

   Weather | Traffic
    Skilling's forecast
    Chicago-area radar


 Business | Tech
 Sports
 Travel
 Health
 Education
 Leisure
 Food
 Entertainment



Voice of the People
A Chicago Tribune Web log for letters to the editor



« Assault on our ears |View today's letters| Pleas to take responsibility »

Originally posted: October 24, 2006
‘Suicide disease’ is a misconception

This is a reply to the Associated Press article recently published titled, "Teen's tongue piercing linked to pain."

The Association of Professional Piercers is a nonprofit health, safety and education organization whose membership is comprised of body piercers and related professionals. Our mission is to disseminate vital information about body piercings to piercers, health care professionals, legislators and the general public. As the medical liaison for the APP, I would like to offer some clarification on the topic of the article.

In the piece, it states the recent Journal of the American Medical Association article linked the Italian teenager’s pain with the condition called trigeminal neuralgia, which is colorfully referred to by its nickname, the "suicide disease." As the JAMA article states, the patient was diagnosed with atypical trigeminal neuralgia, which is much different from typical trigeminal neuralgia.

Typical trigeminal neuralgia is typically caused by compression of the trigeminal nerve root and is characterized by intense, electric-like pain which is often completely debilitating, reportedly bringing many of its sufferers to thoughts of suicide in an effort to deal with the pain. (Hence the nickname, the "suicide disease.")

Atypical trigeminal neuralgia is a less common form of the disorder. Although it is still accompanied by moments of intense pain, it is not characterized by the blinding pain of the former condition. (It most certainly is not the condition referred to as the "suicide disease.")

And although it is infrequent, adjacent dental fillings composed of dissimilar metals may also trigger attacks. The JAMA article alludes to this when it states, "trigeminal neuralgia after a dental alloy implant, possibly triggered by galvanism, has been reported."

While the Associated Press is the model of objective journalism, this article has spawned many newspapers to reprint this piece, in whole or in part, with headlines which imply a link between tongue piercing and typical trigeminal neuralgia. The APP would like to clarify that there is not an established relationship between tongue piercing and typical trigeminal neuralgia, otherwise known as the "suicide disease."

The APP does not attempt to ignore the risks associated with tongue piercings, but we are obviously concerned when these risks are unduly exaggerated. We respectfully wish to correct this error.

James Weber

Medical Liaison

Association of Professional Piercers

Philadelphia, Pa.


Comments

Thank you for running this rebuttable. It's reassuring when papers care enough to stand up to correcting information errors.

Posted by: paul king | Oct 26, 2006 5:41:24 PM


 
All comments are subject to editing and not all submissions will be posted. If posted, readers' e-mail addresses will be available to the public. Comments may be considered for publication in the print version of Voice of the people.
*Denotes required field.

*



*

Contact info

To submit a letter to the editor at the Chicago Tribune, send e-mail or fax to 312-222-2598 or write to Voice of the People, Chicago Tribune, 435 N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, IL 60611.

More on the Web
Find Chicago Tribune columnists, bloggers and editorials at our online opinion page.

Get breaking news and Chicago Tribune news, business, sports and entertainment stories at chicagotribune.com.



Meet the Chicago Tribune editorial board


Last 10 posts
•  Fighting obesity

•  No escaping noise

•  Campaign lessons

•  Fashion on a budget

•  Lack of spirit

•  Appreciate life

•  Teen accidents

•  Driving inexperience

•  A bad idea

•  Ready for college



November 2006 posts
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30

Voice of the People search
Powered by Google


Archives



Subscribe to this blog's feed


Powered by TypePad


Home |  Copyright and terms of service |  Privacy policy |  Subscribe |  Contact us |  Archives |  Advertise |  Site tour